Every Verified listing was checked by a person: references, reviews, license and insurance. How we check

Homeowner guide

Metal or Asphalt Roof for a Minnesota Winter?

For a Minnesota winter, neither metal nor asphalt is the automatic winner. FEMA calls metal panels slippery and asphalt shingles tactile. Metal can shed snow faster, and asphalt tends to hold it. Roof slope and snow guards change how that plays out. Ice dams are a heat and air problem that neither material stops. Check the snow load your roof was designed for, review hail coverage with your insurer, and plan safe snow removal before snow arrives.

How does metal roofing shed snow in winter?

Metal roofing is a slippery surface, so FEMA says it can shed snow more easily than a tactile roof. FEMA P-957 lists metal roof panels as slippery. It lists asphalt shingles and aggregate surface built-up membranes as tactile. Tactile materials are less slippery and do not shed snow as easily.

Slope matters too. FEMA says steeper roof slopes shed snow more effectively. The angle of repose is about a 30 degree roof slope, often written as 6:12 or 7:12. That is the maximum angle at which snow will not slide. FEMA adds that snow on shallower slopes can still slide. Low slope roofs retain snow more than pitched roofs.

Snow guards or snow cleats inhibit snow from sliding off. Without them, a sliding snow condition can occur. If a lower roof sits below your metal roof, ask how snow will land there.

How do asphalt shingles handle snow and ice?

Asphalt shingles are a tactile material, so FEMA says snow does not shed as easily from them as from a slippery surface. FEMA P-957 includes asphalt shingles in its tactile roof materials. It also includes aggregate surface built-up membranes. These surfaces are more abrasive and less slippery. Snow is more likely to stay until it melts or is removed.

This tells you about snow shedding only. Slope, roof temperature and snow guards still affect what happens. A low slope roof, metal or asphalt, retains snow more than a pitched roof. Ice dams can form at the eave on either material when roof surface temperatures are not uniform. The University of Minnesota Extension says the long-term fix is to make the ceiling air tight so warm, moist air cannot flow into the attic, then consider adding ceiling or roof insulation.

Do snow guards stop sliding snow?

Snow guards or snow cleats inhibit snow from sliding off a roof, but FEMA says a sliding snow condition can occur unless a sloped roof has snow guards or cleats. FEMA P-957 warns that snow from a higher roof can slide onto a lower roof where it accumulates. Common cases are porch or sunroom roofs and entrance canopies beneath gabled roofs of homes.

The snow depth on the lower roof within the fall zone can be greater than the overall roof snow depth. The dynamic force of the sliding snow onto the lower roof may produce a significant impact force on the lower roof framing. FEMA says that can potentially overload the roof structure. This is why a lower roof below a metal or asphalt slope deserves attention. Snow guards inhibit sliding, but they are not a substitute for checking the lower roof framing. Ask a contractor how guards, slope and the fall zone work together.

Can a new roof stop ice dams?

No. Neither metal roof panels nor asphalt shingles stop ice dams because ice dams come from nonuniform roof surface temperatures. The University of Minnesota Extension defines an ice dam as a ridge of ice at the edge of a roof that prevents melting snow from draining off the roof. FEMA P-957 says discontinuous thermal characteristics at roof eave overhangs can inhibit snow shedding by causing ice dams. Melt water flows down the roof slope and freezes at the eave.

Ice dams create several problems. They prevent snow from sliding off the roof. They can also allow water infiltration into the building interior. The University of Minnesota Extension says the long-term approach is to make the ceiling air tight so no warm, moist air can flow from the house into the attic space, then consider adding ceiling or roof insulation.

What snow load does Minnesota set for a Chisago County roof?

Minnesota Rules 1303.1700 sets a ground snow load of 50 pounds per square foot in Chisago, Washington, Isanti and Anoka counties and 60 pounds per square foot in Pine County. The rule says that ground snow load is used to determine design snow loads for buildings and other structures. It lists 60 pounds per square foot in listed northern counties, including Pine, and 50 pounds per square foot in all other counties.

That is the code figure to discuss with a designer or contractor. It does not mean every roof has the same capacity. FEMA P-957 lists warning signs of overstress during a snow event. They include popping, cracking or creaking noises, sagging roof members such as metal decking or plywood sheathing, doors or windows that can no longer be opened or closed, cracks in walls and severe roof leaks. If you see them, FEMA says the building should be promptly evacuated and a qualified design professional contacted.

Will my insurance pay for hail damage to a roof?

It depends on your policy. The Minnesota Department of Commerce issued a consumer alert on August 15, 2022 about wind and hail coverage limits. Commerce says some insurers have eliminated coverage for wind and hail damage except when siding or shingles are punctured or torn. Commerce asks homeowners to review their policies and talk with their agent before renewal.

Minnesota law does not address policy exclusions for cosmetic damage from hail or wind. That means the policy language matters. Some policies have a separate, higher deductible for wind and hail. Commerce describes it as a flat rate or 1 percent or more of the home’s replacement value. Read the wind and hail section before you choose a roof material or file a claim.

What is a FORTIFIED roof and does Minnesota require an insurance discount?

A FORTIFIED roof uses the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS) construction method, which goes beyond the building code. The Minnesota Department of Commerce’s Strengthen Minnesota Homes program helps homeowners replace roofs with materials that protect homes against extreme weather like high winds and hail. It uses the FORTIFIED method. Commerce says a fortified roof contains impact-resistant shingles, wider drip edges, sealed roof decks and rain-resistant attic vents.

Minnesota Statutes 65A.298 requires insurers to give a premium discount or rate reduction to owners who build new, or retrofit existing, residential property to meet the IBHS FORTIFIED program standards, including the hail supplement. The owner must provide an IBHS compliance certificate. Discounts apply only to policies that include wind coverage. As of the October 1, 2026 update, Commerce has begun a limited pilot with the Weatherization Assistance Program and is not accepting applications from the general public. Homeowners outside the pilot should not start roofing work expecting a future grant.

How should I remove snow from my roof safely?

FEMA P-957 says snow removal should be performed by a professional roofing contractor who has experience in removing snow from roofs. If you remove snow yourself, FEMA gives clear limits. Removing snow completely from a roof surface can result in serious damage to the roof covering. At least 2 inches of snow should be left on the roof. Do not use sharp tools.

Use a non-metallic snow rake for steep roof slopes if possible. Metal snow rakes can damage roofing material and should be avoided. Snow removal can be conducted from the ground. When using a non-metallic snow rake, be aware that roof snow can slide at any moment. Keep a safe distance from the eave. The University of Minnesota Extension adds that anyone on the roof during the winter, or performing work on the roof from below, risks injury and may cause damage to the roof and house.

Where can I find Chisago County roofers and permit help?

The directory covers 51 roofing businesses in 17 towns around Chisago County, Minnesota. Of those, 17 list metal roofing and 23 list asphalt shingles. Compare the metal roofing roofers or the roof replacement roofers, and before work starts, find your town’s office in the permit guide by town.

Ask each contractor how they handle snow guards, sliding snow onto lower roofs and ice dam causes. Ask how they protect the roof during snow removal. Weigh snow shedding, slope, the lower roof fall zone, your insurance policy and the snow load figure together. Then choose a path that fits your house.

Questions

Does roof insulation change how much snow stays on the roof?

FEMA says a well-insulated or well-ventilated roof typically retains more snow than a poorly insulated roof or a roof over a poorly ventilated attic. An uninsulated heated attic increases the propensity for snow to melt or slide. The University of Minnesota Extension says air sealing and insulation are the long-term approach to ice dams.

What deductible might apply to wind and hail claims?

The Minnesota Department of Commerce says some policies have a separate, higher deductible for wind and hail. It can be a flat rate or 1 percent or more of the home's replacement value. Review your policy and talk with your agent before renewal.

Does the FORTIFIED insurance discount require wind coverage?

Yes. Minnesota Statutes 65A.298 says discounts apply only to policies that include wind coverage. The owner must provide an IBHS compliance certificate for a new or retrofitted home that meets the IBHS FORTIFIED program standards, including the hail supplement.

Can I clear all the snow off my roof?

FEMA says removing snow completely from a roof surface can result in serious damage to the roof covering. At least 2 inches of snow should be left on the roof. Do not use sharp tools. Use a non-metallic snow rake for steep slopes if possible.

Sources: FEMA P-957: Snow Load Safety Guide (January 2013) · University of Minnesota Extension: Dealing with and preventing ice dams · Minnesota Rules 1303.1700: Ground snow load · Minnesota Department of Commerce: Consumer alert on wind and hail coverage limits (August 15, 2022) · Minnesota Department of Commerce: Strengthen Minnesota Homes program · Minnesota Statutes 65A.298: Homeowner's insurance; FORTIFIED program standards